| APrIGF 2026 Session Proposal Submission Form | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part 1 - Lead Organizer | |||||||||||||||
| Contact Person | |||||||||||||||
| Dr. Jeremy Malcolm | |||||||||||||||
| Organization / Affiliation (Please state "Individual" if appropriate) * | |||||||||||||||
| Center for Online Safety and Liberty | |||||||||||||||
| Designation | |||||||||||||||
| Chair | |||||||||||||||
| Gender | |||||||||||||||
| Male | |||||||||||||||
| Economy of Residence | |||||||||||||||
| Australia | |||||||||||||||
| Stakeholder Group | |||||||||||||||
| Civil Society | |||||||||||||||
| Part 2 - Session Proposal | |||||||||||||||
| Session Title | |||||||||||||||
| Drawing the Line: Online Harm, Queer Expression, and Platform Governance in Asia-Pacific | |||||||||||||||
| Thematic Track of Your Session | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Session Format | |||||||||||||||
| Panel Discussion (60 minutes) | |||||||||||||||
| Where do you plan to organize your session? | |||||||||||||||
| Hybrid (with onsite moderator and speakers both online and offline, with online moderator for questions and comments from remote participants) | |||||||||||||||
| Specific Issues for Discussion | |||||||||||||||
| Across the Asia-Pacific region, governments and online platforms are expanding systems intended to protect children and adults from "online harms", including pornography, AI-generated abuse, obscenity, extremism and disinformation. Yet these frameworks increasingly affect communities and forms of expression far beyond their original targets, often disproportionately impacting health promotion, sex worker and LGBTIQ+ communities, fandom creators, artists, and marginalised users. This workshop will explore how online safety regulation and platform governance are reshaping freedom of expression and cultural participation across the Asia-Pacific region. The discussion will draw on examples including platform shadowbanning, criminalisation of fictional or artistic expression, censorship of sex ed and LGBTIQ+ content, and the persistence of colonial-era morality laws that continue to influence digital governance in countries across the region. The session will also introduce and discuss the Drawing the Line Watchlist, a civil society initiative examining how legal systems and platforms distinguish between content involving real victims and forms of fictional, artistic or consensual expression. While child protection and responses to image-based abuse remain critically important goals, the workshop will ask how policymakers can avoid regulatory overreach that collapses these distinctions. Bringing together perspectives from digital rights advocacy, Internet governance, queer policy advocacy, legal scholarship, and fandom studies, the session will explore how to design proportionate, rights-respecting approaches to online harm. Participants will discuss how different regulatory models across the Asia-Pacific region are influencing platform moderation practices, how marginalised communities experience censorship differently, and what safeguards are needed to preserve privacy, anonymity, cultural participation and freedom of expression while still addressing genuine harms. |
|||||||||||||||
| Describe the Relevance of Your Session to APrIGF | |||||||||||||||
| This session directly contributes to the APrIGF 2026 sub-theme of “Digital Resilience and Building of Trust” by examining how online safety and platform governance frameworks can address genuine harms without undermining freedom of expression, privacy, anonymity, and trust among marginalised Internet users. Across the Asia-Pacific region, governments and platforms are increasingly responding to crises such as online abuse, AI-generated harmful content, child safety concerns, disinformation, and cybersecurity threats through expanded regulation and automated moderation systems. However, these measures often lack nuance and context in societies where they are implemented and risk producing unintended consequences that weaken trust in digital platforms and institutions, particularly among sex worker and LGBTIQ+ communities, women, fandom creators, and other marginalized groups whose speech and participation are disproportionately affected by censorship, shadowbanning, surveillance, and overbroad enforcement practices. The session will explore how resilience requires not only technical security, but also social legitimacy and user trust. Internet users are less likely to engage openly online when platforms operate without transparency, when laws blur distinctions between real harm and fictional or consensual expression, or when anonymity and privacy protections are weakened in ways that expose vulnerable communities to surveillance, harassment, or criminalization. The discussion therefore directly engages with the sub-theme’s focus on platform governance, surveillance, child safety, freedom of expression, privacy by design, and the role of digital actors in maintaining an open and trusted Internet ecosystem. |
|||||||||||||||
| Methodology / Agenda (Please add rows by clicking "+" on the right) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Moderators & Speakers Info (Please complete where possible) - (Required) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Please explain the rationale for choosing each of the above contributors to the session. | |||||||||||||||
| Jeremy Malcolm (Center for Online Safety and Liberty) is a digital rights lawyer and lead author of the Drawing the Line Watchlist and Principles, focusing on platform governance, online safety regulation, and freedom of expression. Shambhawi Paudel (ILGA Asia) researches censorship, indirect laws, and shrinking civic space affecting LGBTIQ+ communities across Asia-Pacific, bringing strong regional human rights expertise. Dr K.S. Park (Open Net Korea/Korea University) is a leading expert on Internet freedom, intermediary liability, and platform regulation in Asia. Mish Pony (Flat Out) is the Chief Executive Officer of Flat Out, and former CEO of the Scarlet Alliance, with over 15 years’ experience advocating for trans, queer and sex worker health and rights. |
|||||||||||||||
| Has AI been used to develop this proposal? | |||||||||||||||
| Yes | |||||||||||||||
| How: | |||||||||||||||
| Refining the human-drafted draft session description to improve the phrasing | |||||||||||||||
| Please declare if you have any potential conflict of interest with the Program Committee 2026. | |||||||||||||||
| No | |||||||||||||||
| Are you or other session contributors planning to apply for the APrIGF Fellowship Program 2026? | |||||||||||||||
| No | |||||||||||||||
| Upon evaluation by the Program Committee, your session proposal may only be selected under the condition that you will accept the suggestion of merging with another proposal with similar topics. Please state your preference below: | |||||||||||||||
| Yes, I am willing to work with another session proposer on a suggested merger. | |||||||||||||||
| Brief Summary of Your Session | |||||||||||||||
| The workshop explored how governments and online platforms can address harm without unnecessarily restricting expression, particularly when regulating fictional sexual content. Across legal, digital-rights and queer-community perspectives, discussion focused on the distinctions between representations and actual abuse, the evidence needed to justify restrictions, and the consequences of broad prohibitions. A central issue was the tendency to place fictional depictions within legal categories designed for material documenting child sexual abuse. Participants examined how this can obscure differences in the production of content, the involvement of identifiable victims and the harms alleged to arise from its circulation. The discussion questioned whether the seriousness of a subject depicted in fiction is sufficient grounds for criminalisation, and how regulation should respond when evidence about effects on behaviour is uncertain or contested. The workshop also considered whose expression is most vulnerable to expansive definitions of harm. Examples from across Asia illustrated how morality-based laws and platform restrictions can affect LGBTQI communities, writers and artists. Concerns included the suppression of queer narratives, restrictions on access to information, and survivors’ freedom to describe their own experiences. These examples connected debates about fictional content to wider questions of civic space and the power to determine which forms of expression are acceptable. Another theme was how online-safety agendas are shaped. Discussion addressed assumptions that representation leads to enactment, and concerns that genuine problems such as violence against women and online harassment can be used to advance broader restrictions on sexual and gender expression. Australian developments supplied a comparative perspective on these tensions, alongside regional examples of censorship and platform governance. Proportionality was considered both in the design of laws and in their enforcement. The workshop questioned the application of severe child-protection penalties to fictional depictions and explored possible implications for investigative priorities, sentencing and the allocation of resources. It also considered whether less restrictive approaches—including user controls, clinical support and procedural safeguards—could better address particular risks. Audience contributions connected these issues to local debates about fictional characters, platform regulation and participation in policymaking. The exchanges underscored the need for clear definitions, transparent decision-making and meaningful opportunities to challenge restrictions. Rather than resolving every disagreement about fictional content, the workshop brought attention to the need to identify specific harms, examine supporting evidence and assess whether proposed responses are effective and proportionate. |
|||||||||||||||
| Substantive Summary of the Key Issues Raised and the Discussion | |||||||||||||||
| Jeremy Malcolm from the Center for Online Safety and Liberty introduced the Drawing the Line Principles and Watchlist, which examine laws governing fictional sexual expression. He argued for clear distinctions between material documenting actual child sexual abuse and fictional depictions, and for evidence and proportionality in regulation. His presentation considered the consequences of broad prohibitions for writers, artists and survivors telling their own stories. He also questioned whether expanding criminal enforcement against fictional material advances child protection, highlighting alternatives including user controls, clinical support and due-process safeguards. Shambhawi Paudel from ILGA Asia situated the discussion within shrinking civic space and restrictions on queer expression across Asia. Examples from China, Malaysia and Indonesia illustrated how morality-based laws and platform rules can silence LGBTQI communities and restrict access to information. Paudel also relayed observations supplied by Mish Pony, who could not attend because of illness. Pony’s notes addressed Australian proposals concerning pornography and new categories of “online harms”, assumptions that fictional depictions lead to real-world conduct, and the influence of anti-abortion, anti-LGBTI and conservative Christian organisations on these debates. KS Park from Open Net Korea, joining remotely, examined South Korean restrictions on fictional depictions and the proportionality of applying severe child-protection penalties to cartoons and other representations. He questioned the assumptions underlying these laws and explored their possible effects on enforcement priorities and sentencing. His contribution emphasised the need to assess whether criminal prohibitions produce the protective outcomes claimed for them. Contributions from Taiwan, Pakistan and South Korea, alongside the Taipei local hub, connected the presentations to regional concerns about fictional characters, platform governance and participation in policymaking. Park offered further engagement with Taiwanese advocates on the legal questions raised. The session highlighted the importance of precise definitions, evidence and proportionate responses. Twenty-five copies of the Watchlist were distributed. |
|||||||||||||||
| Conclusions and Suggestions of Way Forward | |||||||||||||||
| The workshop highlighted the importance of distinguishing material documenting actual abuse from fictional representations, and of grounding restrictions in evidence of harm and proportionality. Discussion also underscored the need to consider the effects of regulation on LGBTQI communities, artists, writers and survivors. These were recurring themes rather than formally adopted conclusions. The way forward is to strengthen dialogue between child-protection practitioners, researchers, digital-rights advocates and affected communities; examine the evidence underlying restrictions; and explore responses that protect people while preserving lawful expression. Clearer legal definitions, transparent platform rules and meaningful opportunities to challenge decisions are important elements of this work. A concrete opening for follow-up arose from the exchange with Taiwanese participants, with KS Park offering further engagement on the legal issues raised. The Drawing the Line Principles, Watchlist and workshop recording provide resources for continued regional discussion. COSL’s proposed next research phase, examining platform child-safety governance, transparency and due process, offers a further avenue for developing the questions explored during the session. |
|||||||||||||||
| Number of Attendees (Please fill in numbers) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Gender Balance in Moderators/Speakers (Please fill in numbers) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| How were gender perspectives, equality, inclusion or empowerment discussed? Please provide details and context. | |||||||||||||||
| Gender equality and inclusion were central to the workshop’s examination of whose expression is restricted in the name of safety or morality. Discussion highlighted how broad laws and platform rules can disproportionately affect LGBTQI communities, suppress queer narratives and limit access to information, with examples from China, Malaysia and Indonesia. The workshop also addressed survivors’ autonomy to describe their experiences and the risks of treating sexual expression as inherently harmful. Contributions questioned how genuine concerns about violence against women and online harassment can be used to support restrictions promoted by organisations opposing sexual and gender rights. Empowerment was discussed through the importance of involving affected communities in policymaking, preserving opportunities for self-expression and providing meaningful ways to challenge censorship. |
|||||||||||||||
| Consent | |||||||||||||||
I agree that my data can be submitted to forms.for.asia and processed by APrIGF organizers for the program selection of APrIGF 2026. |
|||||||||||||||
I agree that my data can be submitted to forms.for.asia and processed by APrIGF organizers for the program selection of APrIGF 2026.