| APrIGF 2026 Session Proposal Submission Form | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part 1 - Lead Organizer | |||||||
| Contact Person | |||||||
| Mr. Nilay Shah | |||||||
| Organization / Affiliation (Please state "Individual" if appropriate) * | |||||||
| Software Freedom Law Center, India (SFLC.in) | |||||||
| Designation | |||||||
| Volunteer Legal Counsel | |||||||
| Gender | |||||||
| Male | |||||||
| Economy of Residence | |||||||
| India | |||||||
| Stakeholder Group | |||||||
| Civil Society | |||||||
| Part 2 - Session Proposal | |||||||
| Session Title | |||||||
| Appealing Hate Speech- Using the Grievance Appellate Committee to Hold Platforms Accountable | |||||||
| Thematic Track of Your Session | |||||||
|
|||||||
| Session Format | |||||||
| Lightning Talk (20 minutes) | |||||||
| Where do you plan to organize your session? | |||||||
| Offsite from the venue at a local hub (with online moderator for questions and comments from remote participants) | |||||||
| Specific Issues for Discussion | |||||||
| In India and the world over, Big Tech has waged war against the global efforts to regulate platforms. Meta in 2025 rolled back its fact checking unit in the United States and also made sweeping changes to its “Harmful Conduct” community standards. X has seen unprecedented levels of hate speech engagement, with persistent year on year increases since 2022. Efforts by Governments to enforce regulation have met either silence, as was the case with Nepal, or reluctant acquiescence, as with India. A collateral of this tussle has been the exponential increase in unchecked hate speech, that is platformed for vague reasons of free speech, political pressure, or sheer disregard on the part of platforms. With content moderation and review increasingly becoming AI driven, and with the ever changing enforcement standards becoming politically charged, recourse in terms of the takedown or restoration of content on platforms has become a coin toss at best. One of the was that we have worked to counter the same is by leveraging internal grievance redressal mechanisms, and government bodies such as the Grievance Appellate Committee in India, an online forum for users to appeal decisions issued by Grievance Officers of intermediaries. The GAC is staffed by Members appointed by the Central Government. Decisions by the GAC are binding on platforms. SFLC.in has filed upward of 60 appeals at the GAC, focusing on hate speech, and our successes and challenges provide a good model for other jurisdictions to consider. So far, we have successfully appealed the takedown of 20 pieces of content, challenged a further 3 at the High Court Level, and through our analysis, ideated an alternative model for what a good Appellate Authority should look like. Replicating such a model would provide citizens access to a more trustworthy, safe, and resilient internet- and a method to hold platforms accountable in the current system of asymmetric power imbalances. |
|||||||
| Describe the Relevance of Your Session to APrIGF | |||||||
| The session falls squarely under the theme of building digital resilience, with a focus on platform accountability and governance. Practices such as the GAC mechanism in India, the DSA appeals mechanism, and the Oversight Board mechanism help build digital resilience, particularly in a time when holding platforms accountable seems increasingly out of reach. Our experience with the GAC particularly will help CSOs grapple with the question of platform accountability and hate speech through what is a unique approach, leveraging both private and public modes of redressal to counter hate speech online. An expected outcome for this session is for organizations working in South Asia to grapple with questions of intermediary liability. The so called "Delhi Effect" has resulted in Bangladesh for example transplanting Indian laws without considering the ill effects of the same. By highlighting our practical experience, we aim to ensure that laws modeled along the lines of India's intermediary liability regime do not suffer the same pitfalls. The internet is also a global landscape. We have in our experience noticed that using the GAC mechanism is often helpful to take down hate speech not just within India, but globally. Experience with its working could therefore help CSOs action hate speech in their jurisdictions through partnerships with us, particularly when their countries have more lax intermediary liability provisions. |
|||||||
| Methodology / Agenda (Please add rows by clicking "+" on the right) | |||||||
|
|||||||
| Moderators & Speakers Info (Please complete where possible) - (Required) | |||||||
|
|||||||
| Please explain the rationale for choosing each of the above contributors to the session. | |||||||
| I, Nilay Shah, have worked extensively on platform accountability, particularly on the GAC mechanism in India. I have filed upwards of 70 GAC appeals, reviewed and analysed decisions, and written about the pitfalls, successes, and changes required. Additionally, I have also filed a petition before the High Court of Kerala on the same. |
|||||||
| Has AI been used to develop this proposal? | |||||||
| No | |||||||
| Please declare if you have any potential conflict of interest with the Program Committee 2026. | |||||||
| No | |||||||
| Are you or other session contributors planning to apply for the APrIGF Fellowship Program 2026? | |||||||
| No | |||||||
| Upon evaluation by the Program Committee, your session proposal may only be selected under the condition that you will accept the suggestion of merging with another proposal with similar topics. Please state your preference below: | |||||||
| Yes, I am willing to work with another session proposer on a suggested merger. | |||||||
| APrIGF offers live transcripts in English for all sessions. Do you need any disability related requirements for your session? APrIGF makes every effort to be a fully inclusive and accessible event, and will do the best to fulfill your needs. | |||||||
| None, thank you | |||||||
| Brief Summary of Your Session | |||||||
| Over the past few months, SFLC.in has engaged in an empirical analysis backed by research driven data on the Grievance Appellate Committee (GAC), an online dispute resolution mechanism. The entire appeal process, from filing to decision, is in digital mode. Our experience with the GAC has shown that it is a unique quasi-judicial platform that provides quick resolution, ease of appealing, and binding decisions. The session went into detail to describe the process followed, outcomes, challenges, and gaps. It included- 1. What is the GAC 2. How to file a GAC appeal 3. A summary of 4 appeals we filed with differing decisions 4. A brief of the challenge we made at the High Court level. 5. Statistics and trends. |
|||||||
| Substantive Summary of the Key Issues Raised and the Discussion | |||||||
| GAC APPEALS GAC Appeal 15638/2025 : rejected as ‘premature’. Meta claimed no specific GO decision was challenged, despite screenshots of the GO’s reply being submitted as evidence. GAC Appeal 16713/2025 : rejected on same grounds as above. GAC Appeal 16714/2025 : rejected on grounds of being similar to first appeal filed, although Instagram page and Instagram posts challenged were different. GAC might be relying on AI to filter similarly worded appeals. RTI filed to inquire about that received no response and has been appealed. GAC Appeal 19422/2025 : GO replied in 90 days, in violation of 15 day deadline. GAC decided after 4 months despite timeline of 30 days being prescribed. Meta claimed appeal filed beyond 30 day limit, failing to acknowledge GO’s delay. All 5 posts taken down despite Meta’s statement that 3 of them did not violate Community Guidelines. TRENDS- Both the number of appeals filed and the number of pending appeals has been steadily increasing. Over a 10 month period from Jan-Nov 2025, 3667 appeals were filed. In a similar 10 month period from Nov-Sep 2026, 57364 appeals were filed, around a 1500% increase. Correspondingly, while 3734 appeals were resolved in the Jan-Nov period, 7560 appeals were resolved in the Nov-Sep period. While appeals have increased fifteen fold, the number of appeals disposed has only increased two fold. This has resulted in resolutions being significantly delayed. Appeals now take an average of 90-100 days to be resolved. Some appeals pending beyond 120 days CHALLENGES Lack of transparency- users cannot see contentions of platforms Going through the motions- lack of consideration of evidence submitted Delays by Grievance Officer- sometimes extending up to 3 months. GAC orders rarely in favour when an appeal is filed on the grounds that GO did not reply Platforms reverse decisions just prior to GAC passing an order Significant delays - GAC takes up to 4 months or more to pass an order Cannot approach Court until an order is passed |
|||||||
| Conclusions and Suggestions of Way Forward | |||||||
| FIXES Users should be allowed to view and respond to platform contentions- increased transparency. This would greatly reduce the power imbalance a user faces when compared to a platform. It would go a step toward leveling the asymmetric distribution of resources and knowledge that a platform, represented by lawyers has, versus a regular user. Increasing the number of benches and having human rights experts as parts of panels. Publishing orders online- creates precedent and increases predictability |
|||||||
| Number of Attendees (Please fill in numbers) | |||||||
|
|||||||
| Gender Balance in Moderators/Speakers (Please fill in numbers) | |||||||
|
|||||||
| How were gender perspectives, equality, inclusion or empowerment discussed? Please provide details and context. | |||||||
| This was a lightning talk, I was the only speaker. However, the discussion centered around challenging hate speech online, and gave attendees a way to challenge hate speech and OGBV in India. | |||||||
| Consent | |||||||
I agree that my data can be submitted to forms.for.asia and processed by APrIGF organizers for the program selection of APrIGF 2026. |
|||||||
I agree that my data can be submitted to forms.for.asia and processed by APrIGF organizers for the program selection of APrIGF 2026.