| APrIGF 2026 Session Proposal Submission Form | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part 1 - Lead Organizer | |||||||||||||||
| Contact Person | |||||||||||||||
| Mr. Unggul Sagena | |||||||||||||||
| Organization / Affiliation (Please state "Individual" if appropriate) * | |||||||||||||||
| SAFEnet (Southeast Asia Freedom of Expression Network) | |||||||||||||||
| Designation | |||||||||||||||
| Head of Internet Access | |||||||||||||||
| Gender | |||||||||||||||
| Male | |||||||||||||||
| Economy of Residence | |||||||||||||||
| Indonesia | |||||||||||||||
| Stakeholder Group | |||||||||||||||
| Civil Society | |||||||||||||||
| List Your Organizing Partners (if any) | |||||||||||||||
| Maria Xynou, OONI (Open Observatory of Network Interference), maria@openobservatory.org Sohini Rajiyung, Internet Society (ISOC), rajiyung@isoc.org |
|||||||||||||||
| Part 2 - Session Proposal | |||||||||||||||
| Session Title | |||||||||||||||
| Closing the Last-Mile Gap: A Civil Society Approach to Internet Quality Measurement in Rural Indonesia | |||||||||||||||
| Thematic Track of Your Session | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Session Format | |||||||||||||||
| Showcase (30 minutes) | |||||||||||||||
| Where do you plan to organize your session? | |||||||||||||||
| Hybrid (with onsite moderator and speakers both online and offline, with online moderator for questions and comments from remote participants) | |||||||||||||||
| Specific Issues for Discussion | |||||||||||||||
| This session asks what households in underserved Indonesian regions actually receive, drawing on 109 community measurements across six districts on five islands (2025–2026). It covers four issues. Reported vs lived connectivity. Indonesia reports 80.66% penetration and a national median download of 62.54 Mbps. Community measurements find a household median of 19.8 Mbps, about a third, with 90% of readings below the national figure. What does this mean for universal service targets built on aggregate numbers? Inequality inside districts. Medians are similar across sites, yet readings within one district range from 0.31 to over 90 Mbps. Java, with the highest reported penetration, shows more sub-10 Mbps connections than sites outside it. Can coverage-led policy address a divide driven by contention and affordability? Single-operator dependence. Outside Java, one operator group carries up to three-quarters of measured connections. The 2025 SMPCS cable break isolated eleven Papuan districts for months. How can local measurement flag exposed communities before an outage? Whose experience data reflects? Industry surveys count users, commercial indices aggregate voluntary tests, ministries report infrastructure built. Community measurement is small but grounded in residents' own devices and homes. We will discuss its limits, similar experiences elsewhere in the Asia-Pacific, and how to extend it to regions such as Papua, which are not yet measured. Issues 1–2 relate to Universal and Meaningful Connectivity; 3–4 to Digital Resilience and Building of Trust; and to the overarching theme by asking which communities are most exposed before a crisis arrives. |
|||||||||||||||
| Describe the Relevance of Your Session to APrIGF | |||||||||||||||
| Universal, Meaningful Connectivity. Regional debate has moved from whether people are online to whether access is usable, affordable and reliable. This session brings evidence from the ground: households in six Indonesian districts receive about a third of the reported national median, with inequality inside districts that averages conceal. We will discuss what meaningful connectivity requires in practice, why penetration figures alone mislead policy, and how universal service targets could better reflect underserved communities' experience. Digital Resilience and Building of Trust. Resilience depends on redundancy, and frontier districts have the least: outside Java, one operator group carries up to three-quarters of measured connections. The 2025 SMPCS cable break in Papua shows the cost. The session also addresses trust in evidence. Most connectivity figures come from industry associations, commercial platforms or governments reporting on their own programmes. Community measurement adds an independent perspective grounded in residents' own devices and homes. Overarching theme. Safeguarding a resilient internet in times of crisis requires knowing, before a crisis, which communities are most exposed. Citizen-generated measurement can help provide that early picture, revealing weak links in coverage, quality and operator diversity that aggregate statistics hide. Expected outcomes -Present findings from six Indonesian districts and the method behind them: a simple testing protocol paired with a one-day community workshop. -Gather comparable experiences from other Asia-Pacific economies on gaps between reported and lived connectivity. -Explore where and how the approach could apply beyond Indonesia, and what adaptations it would need. Identify support from technical communities, civil society, researchers and other stakeholders, particularly to extend measurement into Papua and other under-measured islands. -Inputs for preparation of measurement reports by SAFEnet. |
|||||||||||||||
| Methodology / Agenda (Please add rows by clicking "+" on the right) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Moderators & Speakers Info (Please complete where possible) - (Required) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Please explain the rationale for choosing each of the above contributors to the session. | |||||||||||||||
| Unggul, Head of SAFEnet's Internet Access Division, technology & society policy expert, designed and led this measurement and capacity-building programme since 2025 as part of his enduring advocacy in Internet access and connectivity in the region. Ramzy, digital law expert, contributes to research, advocacy and follow-ups of the measurements, especially for law and technology advocacies. Maria, Director of Strategic Engagement at OONI — the tool used throughout — brings global comparative perspective on community-based quality monitoring and ties to OONI's wider partner network. Sohini, Internet Society's Community Engagement Manager for Asia Pacific, grounds the discussion in the region's Universal and Meaningful Connectivity agenda and Internet Society's Community-Centered Connectivity (CCC) program. Together, the four span civil-society leadership, technical/open-measurement expertise, and international policy perspectives, strengthening both rigor and inclusion/diversity. | |||||||||||||||
| Has AI been used to develop this proposal? | |||||||||||||||
| Yes | |||||||||||||||
| How: | |||||||||||||||
| grammar and time frame | |||||||||||||||
| Please declare if you have any potential conflict of interest with the Program Committee 2026. | |||||||||||||||
| No | |||||||||||||||
| Are you or other session contributors planning to apply for the APrIGF Fellowship Program 2026? | |||||||||||||||
| No | |||||||||||||||
| Upon evaluation by the Program Committee, your session proposal may only be selected under the condition that you will accept the suggestion of merging with another proposal with similar topics. Please state your preference below: | |||||||||||||||
| Yes, I am willing to work with another session proposer on a suggested merger. | |||||||||||||||
| Brief Summary of Your Session | |||||||||||||||
| SAFEnet presented community measurements showing that households in six rural Indonesian districts receive about a third of the national median download speed. In 2025 and 2026, residents of Blitar, Serang, Solok, Polewali Mandar, Sepaku/IKN and Labuan Bajo attended one-day digital rights workshops. They installed OONI Probe on their own phones, tested later from where they live, and sent a screenshot with each result. SAFEnet checked each result against its screenshot and accepted 103 of 109. The accepted readings had a median download speed of 19.0 Mbps, against Ookla’s national mobile median of 62.54 Mbps for May 2026. Of the 103, 94 fell below the national figure and 26 fell below 10 Mbps. Ramzy Muliawan (SAFEnet) presented and Unggul Sagena (SAFEnet) moderated. Maria Xynou (OONI) responded online and Sohini Rajiyung (Internet Society) responded onsite. |
|||||||||||||||
| Substantive Summary of the Key Issues Raised and the Discussion | |||||||||||||||
| Speeds varied more within districts than between them. In one Labuan Bajo sub-district, a community training centre measured 0.16 Mbps and a home 47.7 Mbps; a district average hides that spread. All eleven readings above 50 Mbps came from mobile networks, while fixed and Wi-Fi connections peaked at 43 Mbps (connection type inferred from the operator each participant named). The national penetration rate of 80.66% (APJII, 2025) counts who is online, not the speed they get. In the three 2026 workshops, participants’ knowledge index rose from 48.1 to 64.7 (n=58). The 2025 Sorong–Timika–Merauke cable break cut eleven Papuan districts off for months, but SAFEnet has yet to measure in Papua. Indonesia’s national mobile median ranks 74th globally, behind Brunei, Vietnam, Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand and Cambodia. The community median of 19.0 Mbps falls below the lowest ASEAN mobile median SAFEnet compared (Laos at 42.85 Mbps) Maria Xynou called the gap between national figures and household measurements concerning. OONI Probe records location only at country level, and OONI plans an experiment on sub-national location data and a user survey. She encouraged extending the study to Papua. Sohini Rajiyung said measurement does not need to be complicated and urged SAFEnet to use the data in advocacy. She cited communities that relied on amateur radio after disasters. She noted that Starlink and similar satellite services lack licences in some countries, and asked who pays the running costs. She offered links to the Internet Society’s community networks work, to submarine cable and IXP data, and to a community network practitioner in the Philippines. A participant in the room asked whether measurement data leads to accountability, including for throttling in Papua; the answer cited SAFEnet’s successful challenge in the Jakarta administrative court. The same participant asked how SAFEnet protects volunteer measurers if authorities surveil or detain them; in reply to an online question, the moderator said the programme collects no subscriber IDs, device IDs or GPS coordinates, and that participation is voluntary. |
|||||||||||||||
| Conclusions and Suggestions of Way Forward | |||||||||||||||
| SAFEnet proposed a shared minimum schema for community measurement in underserved and frontier areas: speed in both directions, with units fixed; location to sub-district level; operator; test setting and time; a screenshot as evidence; and publication of every record, with exclusions flagged. One country’s dataset can be dismissed as unrepresentative, but datasets collected to the same schema in several Asia Pacific economies would show whether the threefold gap is Indonesian or regional. SAFEnet will publish the record-level dataset and wants to extend the workshops to Papua with OONI and the Internet Society. It invited groups in the Pacific islands, Nepal and eastern Indonesia to run the same workshops. |
|||||||||||||||
| Number of Attendees (Please fill in numbers) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| Gender Balance in Moderators/Speakers (Please fill in numbers) | |||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||
| How were gender perspectives, equality, inclusion or empowerment discussed? Please provide details and context. | |||||||||||||||
| Moderators and speakers were two women (Maria Xynou, OONI; Sohini Rajiyung, Internet Society) and two men (Ramzy Muliawan and Unggul Sagena, SAFEnet). Because the measurement form omits participants’ gender, SAFEnet cannot yet break down the results by gender. On inclusion, the workshops require only a phone and the skill to use it, and participants measured from their own homes in rural and frontier districts. SAFEnet has yet to measure in Papua, the region with the lowest reported penetration (69.26%). For indigenous and remote communities, poor access limits advocacy on land rights, the environment and extractive projects. A participant asked how SAFEnet protects volunteer measurers; the programme collects no subscriber IDs, device IDs or GPS coordinates. |
|||||||||||||||
| Consent | |||||||||||||||
I agree that my data can be submitted to forms.for.asia and processed by APrIGF organizers for the program selection of APrIGF 2026. |
|||||||||||||||
I agree that my data can be submitted to forms.for.asia and processed by APrIGF organizers for the program selection of APrIGF 2026.